The Philadelphia Phillies are making moves this offseason to retool their roster after a disappointing playoff exit. With the signing of outfielder Max Kepler, speculation is mounting that the Phillies might part ways with Brandon Marsh, a key piece of their outfield. The decision could signal a significant shift in their strategy as they look toward the 2025 season.
Max Kepler’s Arrival Shakes Up the Phillies’ Outfield
The addition of Max Kepler brings a new dynamic to the Phillies‘ lineup. Known for his power at the plate, Kepler has consistently delivered as a middle-of-the-order hitter during his career with the Minnesota Twins. Averaging 24 home runs and 77 RBIs per season, Kepler offers a stronger offensive presence compared to Brandon Marsh, who has primarily been a bottom-of-the-lineup player.
Kepler’s signing not only enhances the Phillies’ offensive potential but also creates a crowded outfield. With Kepler, Kyle Schwarber, and Bryce Harper likely to occupy key spots, Marsh’s future with the team is now uncertain.
Brandon Marsh’s Inconsistencies Raise Concerns
Brandon Marsh has been a steady, if not spectacular, player for the Phillies since joining the team in 2022. In the 2024 season, he posted a .249 batting average with career highs of 16 home runs and 19 stolen bases. While these numbers are respectable, they don’t quite match the consistency or offensive firepower the Phillies need to contend for a championship.
Much of Marsh’s production was concentrated in a standout month of June, where he slashed an impressive .298/.411/.426. However, his performance over the rest of the season was uneven, leaving questions about his reliability as an everyday player.
With the team aiming for sustained postseason success, Marsh’s limited offensive impact could make him expendable—especially when compared to Kepler’s proven track record.
Why Marsh Could Be a Trade Asset
Despite his inconsistencies, Brandon Marsh remains an attractive trade asset due to his age and years of team control. At just 26 years old, Marsh won’t become a free agent until after the 2027 season. This extended team control, coupled with his potential for growth, could make him a valuable piece for teams looking to rebuild or add depth to their outfield.
Spotrac projects Marsh to sign an eight-year, $136 million deal when he eventually hits free agency. For the Phillies, trading Marsh now could bring in the pitching or infield depth they need, while also clearing space for Kepler and their other established outfielders.
The Bigger Picture for the Phillies
The Phillies’ decision to sign Max Kepler and potentially move on from Brandon Marsh reflects their focus on assembling a roster capable of winning now. With a lineup that already includes stars like Bryce Harper and Trea Turner, adding more offensive consistency is crucial.
While parting with a young, controllable player like Marsh isn’t an easy choice, the Phillies seem committed to making bold moves this offseason. Whether or not Marsh is traded, it’s clear that Philadelphia is positioning itself to be a top contender in 2025.
The Phillies are at a crossroads with their outfield. Max Kepler’s signing has added depth and power but also raised tough questions about Brandon Marsh’s role. If the team decides to trade Marsh, it could bring back valuable pieces to round out their roster.
With the stakes higher than ever, the Phillies are showing they’re willing to make the necessary changes to compete for a championship. This offseason might be the turning point that sets the tone for their future success.
